Heavy Lifting - thoughts and web finds by an economist
|I also contribute to Division of Labour||Load HL's Front Page|
Friday, May 15, 2009
It took some work, but I was finally able to get the list of Chrysler dealerships on the chopping block into MS Excel and eventually accumulate the number of dealerships per state. There might be another tally by state but I couldn't find one via Google.
Here's a scatter plot of the number of dealerships per one million population against state economic freedom and whether the state went for Obama in the 2008 election:
Here is a tabulation by state of the number of dealerships to be closed.
Here are the results from a negative binomial estimation where the number of dealers is the dependent variables:
There isn't much here. There is weak evidence that states that voted for Obama in the presidential election of 2008 suffer more closed dealerships. Perhaps that is a political calculation? If these states suffere the most but are also the safest in terms of Obama's future presidential hopes then perhaps the number of dealership closings is non-random. However, economic freedom and per-capita income do not seem to have any relationship to the number of dealerships closing.
Stata data file
It seems more likely that those states with the largest number of dealerships in danger of being closed would be the most likely to vote for Obama in the first place in order to increase the chance that they would be saved. It's possible that those states didn't have as many closures as they would have under McCain, but of course there's no way to test for that.
Your results might just indicate that the states with the largest number of at-risk dealerships before the election were more likely to vote for Obama. But these states still had the most dealership closures after the election.
Not sure I trust p values for a limiting distribution with 50 obs and small sample sampling distribution unknown, but did you think maybe it's just selection bias? Swing states that were slumping seemed to have swung Obama's way, and are most likely to have ANY business close, including (maybe especially) auto dealerships.Post a Comment
Le Chai - galerie du vin
Posts that contain Craig Depken per day for the last 90 days.
Heavy Lifting's Main Page
Money I Found Today
Heavy Lifting - Firehose style (56k warning)
- Any Pattern in Chrysler Dealership Closings?
Modified maystar design
powered by blogger